Organic Chemistry

Reaction Intermediates & Reagents

The short lived species that decide reaction pathways: bond fission, electrophiles and nucleophiles, carbocations and their rearrangements, carbanions, free radicals, carbenes and nitrenes

NEET style

Stability orders of carbocations and free radicals, homolytic and heterolytic fission, classifying reagents as electrophiles or nucleophiles, and the shape of carbocations, all within NCERT

JEE style

Carbocation rearrangements (hydride and methyl shifts) predicting major products, carbene reactions (dichlorocarbene, cyclopropanation), aromatic ions and mixed effect stability comparisons

Bond fission and reagents

Homolytic fission

  • Each atom takes one electron (shown with a half headed, fish hook arrow)
  • Gives free radicals; such reactions are called free radical, homopolar or nonpolar
  • Favoured by light, heat, peroxides, nonpolar bonds

Heterolytic fission

  • One atom takes both electrons
  • Gives ions (carbocation + anion, or carbanion + cation); such reactions are called ionic, heteropolar or polar
  • Favoured by polar bonds and polar solvents

Electrophiles (E⁺, take away an electron pair)

  • HX+\ce{H+}, NOX2X+\ce{NO2+}, ClX+\ce{Cl+}, BrX+\ce{Br+}, carbocations (RX+\ce{R+}), CHX3COX+\ce{CH3CO+}
  • Neutral: BFX3\ce{BF3}, AlClX3\ce{AlCl3}, SOX3\ce{SO3}, and molecules with an electrophilic carbon such as the carbonyl carbon or the carbon of an alkyl halide (NCERT)
  • Dichlorocarbene, :CClX2\ce{:CCl2} (beyond NCERT)

Nucleophiles (Nu:, bring an electron pair)

  • OHX−\ce{OH-}, CNX−\ce{CN-}, ROX−\ce{RO-}, HSX−\ce{HS-}, XX−\ce{X-}, carbanions
  • Neutral with lone pairs: HX2O\ce{H2O}, NHX3\ce{NH3}, RX3N\ce{R3N}, RX2NH\ce{R2NH}, ROH\ce{ROH}

Carbocations

A carbocation (earlier called a carbonium ion) has a positively charged carbon with only six electrons: sp² hybridised and trigonal planar, with an empty p orbital perpendicular to the molecular plane. It is primary, secondary or tertiary according to how many carbons are bonded to the positive carbon. Anything that donates electron density into the empty p orbital stabilises it; NCERT explains the order CHX3X+<CHX3CHX2X+<(CHX3)X2CHX+<(CHX3)X3CX+\ce{CH3+} < \ce{CH3CH2+} < \ce{(CH3)2CH+} < \ce{(CH3)3C+} by the inductive effect and hyperconjugation of the alkyl groups.

Stability
(CX6HX5)X3CX+>(CX6HX5)X2CHX+>CX6HX5CHX2X+≈CHX2=CHCHX2X+≈3∘>2∘>1∘>CHX3X+\ce{(C6H5)3C+} > \ce{(C6H5)2CH+} > \ce{C6H5CH2+} \approx \ce{CH2=CHCH2+} \approx 3^\circ > 2^\circ > 1^\circ > \ce{CH3+}

The aryl and allyl part is beyond NCERT Class 11; NCERT’s haloalkanes unit notes that allylic and benzylic cations are stabilised by resonance

  • Stabilised by +I, hyperconjugation and especially resonance (allyl, benzyl, adjacent O/N lone pair).
  • Destabilised by −I groups: CFX3CHX2X+\ce{CF3CH2+} is very unstable.
  • Vinyl (CHX2=CHX+\ce{CH2=CH+}) and phenyl cations are very unstable (charge on an sp carbon, or in an sp² orbital in the ring plane).
  • The tropylium (cycloheptatrienyl) cation is aromatic (6π) and unusually stable.
(CHX3)X3C−CH(OH)CHX3→−HX2OHX+(CHX3)X3C−CHX+CHX3→1,2-CHX3 shift(CHX3)X2CX+−CH(CHX3)X2→(CHX3)X2C=C(CHX3)X2\ce{(CH3)3C-CH(OH)CH3 ->[H+][-H2O] (CH3)3C-CH+CH3 ->[1,2-CH3 shift] (CH3)2C+-CH(CH3)2 -> (CH3)2C=C(CH3)2}

3,3-Dimethylbutan-2-ol gives 2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene as the major product via a methyl shift

Carbanions and free radicals

Carbanion

  • 8 electrons, negative charge
  • NCERT: formed when carbon keeps the bonding pair in heterolysis (for example the methyl anion); unstable and reactive
  • Beyond NCERT: sp³ (pyramidal), sp² if conjugated
  • Beyond NCERT: stability CHX3X−>1∘>2∘>3∘\ce{CH3-} > 1^\circ > 2^\circ > 3^\circ
  • Stabilised by −I and −M (enolates, benzyl, allyl) and by greater s character (ethynide)
  • Cyclopentadienyl anion is aromatic

Free radical

  • 7 electrons, neutral, paramagnetic
  • NCERT: formed by homolysis with heat or light; very reactive
  • sp² (planar) or shallow pyramid (beyond NCERT)
  • Stability (NCERT): 3∘>2∘>1∘>CHX3 ⋅ 3^\circ > 2^\circ > 1^\circ > \ce{CH3.}
  • Stabilised by hyperconjugation and resonance
  • Triphenylmethyl radical is persistent

Radical stability explains selectivity in free radical halogenation (NCERT: hydrogens are replaced in the order 3° > 2° > 1°) and anti Markovnikov HBr addition in the presence of peroxide. Only HBr shows this peroxide (Kharash) effect: the H–Cl bond (430.5 kJ mol−1^{-1}) is too strong to be broken by the radical, unlike H–Br (363.7 kJ mol−1^{-1}), while the iodine atoms from the weak H–I bond (296.8 kJ mol−1^{-1}) combine to IX2\ce{I2} instead of adding.

Carbenes and nitrenes (beyond NCERT)

A carbene (RX2C:\ce{R2C:}) is a neutral divalent carbon with six valence electrons. Singlet carbenes have both nonbonding electrons paired (sp², bent, electrophilic); triplet carbenes have two unpaired electrons (more stable for CHX2\ce{CH2} itself, behave like diradicals).

CHClX3+OHX−→X−X22−CClX3+HX2O→:CClX2+ClX−\ce{CHCl3 + OH- -> {}^{-}CCl3 + H2O -> :CCl2 + Cl-}

Dichlorocarbene forms by α-elimination; it is the electrophile in the Reimer Tiemann reaction and the carbylamine test, which NCERT describes without the carbene

Singlet carbenes add to alkenes stereospecifically to give cyclopropanes (cis-alkene → cis-cyclopropane) and insert into C–H bonds. Sources: diazomethane (CHX2NX2\ce{CH2N2}) on photolysis, chloroform + base.

A nitrene (R−N:\ce{R-N:}) is the nitrogen analogue (six valence electrons). Acyl nitrenes (or concerted equivalents) appear in the Hofmann and Curtius rearrangements, where an alkyl or aryl group migrates from carbon to nitrogen to form an isocyanate. NCERT states only the migration step: in the Hofmann bromamide reaction the alkyl or aryl group moves from the carbonyl carbon of the amide to nitrogen.

Formula bank

Carbocation stability

3∘>2∘>1∘>CHX3X+3^\circ > 2^\circ > 1^\circ > \ce{CH3+}

Carbanion stability (beyond NCERT)

CHX3X−>1∘>2∘>3∘\ce{CH3-} > 1^\circ > 2^\circ > 3^\circ

Radical stability

3∘>2∘>1∘>CHX3 ⋅ 3^\circ > 2^\circ > 1^\circ > \ce{CH3.}

Dichlorocarbene (beyond NCERT)

CHClX3+KOH→:CClX2+KCl+HX2O\ce{CHCl3 + KOH -> :CCl2 + KCl + H2O}

Cyclopropanation (beyond NCERT)

RX2C=CRX2+:CHX2→cyclopropane\ce{R2C=CR2 + :CH2 -> cyclopropane}

Diazomethane photolysis (beyond NCERT)

CHX2NX2→hν:CHX2+NX2\ce{CH2N2 ->[h\nu] :CH2 + N2}

Tricks & mnemonics

Cations love donors, anions love acceptors

Carbocations: +I, +M, hyperconjugation stabilise. Carbanions: −I, −M stabilise; alkyl groups destabilise.

Radicals behave like cations

Radical stability follows the carbocation order (3° > 2° > 1°), not the carbanion order.

Always ask “can it shift?”

After forming a carbocation, look one carbon over: a hydride or methyl that can move to give 3° (or a less strained ring) will move.

Aromatic ions

Cyclopropenyl⁺ (2π), cyclopentadienyl⁻ (6π), tropylium⁺ (6π) are aromatic and unusually stable; cyclopentadienyl⁺ (4π) is antiaromatic (a term beyond NCERT).

Electron count

Carbocation 6, carbene 6, radical 7, carbanion 8 valence electrons on carbon.

NCERT high yield lines

Original NCERT aligned summaries of the lines examiners love. Tap “Quiz me” to test yourself instantly.

  • Carbocations are sp² hybridised and trigonal planar, with an empty p orbital; stability rises from methyl to primary, secondary and tertiary because of the inductive and hyperconjugation effects of alkyl groups.Class 11 · Unit 8
  • Homolytic cleavage gives free radicals (free radical or nonpolar reactions); heterolytic cleavage gives ions (ionic or polar reactions).Class 11 · Unit 8
  • A nucleophile brings an electron pair (nucleus seeking) and an electrophile takes one away (electron seeking); carbocations and the carbon of C=O or C–X groups are electrophilic centres.Class 11 · Unit 8
  • Heterolysis in which carbon keeps the bonding pair gives a carbanion, such as the methyl anion; like carbocations and free radicals, carbanions are unstable and reactive.Class 11 · Unit 8
  • Alkyl free radicals become more stable from methyl to primary, secondary and tertiary.Class 11 · Unit 8

Solved problems

Example 1
NEETFoundation
Arrange in decreasing stability: CHX3X+\ce{CH3+}, (CHX3)X3CX+\ce{(CH3)3C+}, CHX3CHX2X+\ce{CH3CH2+}, (CHX3)X2CHX+\ce{(CH3)2CH+}.
  1. A3° > 2° > 1° > methyl
  2. Bmethyl > 1° > 2° > 3°
  3. C2° > 3° > 1° > methyl
  4. Dall equal
Example 2
JEE MainFoundation
Which carbanion is the most stable: CHX3X−\ce{CH3-}, CHX3CHX2X−\ce{CH3CH2-}, (CHX3)X2CHX−\ce{(CH3)2CH-}, (CHX3)X3CX−\ce{(CH3)3C-}?
Example 3
JEE MainJEE AdvancedExam level
Predict the major alkene from acid catalysed dehydration of 3,3-dimethylbutan-2-ol.
Example 4
JEE AdvancedExam level
Explain why cyclopenta-1,3-diene (pKaK_a ≈ 16) is far more acidic than most hydrocarbons (pKaK_a ≈ 50).
Example 5
JEE MainExam level
How is dichlorocarbene generated, and is it an electrophile or a nucleophile?

Practice

Q1
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Important
Which is a nucleophile?
Q2
Single correct
JEE MainFoundation
Important
The most stable carbanion is:
Q3
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Important
Which radical is the most stable?
Q4
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedExam level
Important
Acid catalysed dehydration of 3,3-dimethylbutan-2-ol mainly gives:
Q5
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Important
The major product of the addition of HCl to 3-methylbut-1-ene is:
Q6
Single correct
NEETFoundation
The carbon of a free radical has how many valence electrons?
Q7
Single correct
NEETFoundation
The hybridisation of the carbon in a carbocation is:
Q8
Single correct
JEE MainFoundation
Dichlorocarbene is the reactive intermediate in:
Q9
One or more correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedExam level
Which species are aromatic?
Q10
Numerical
JEE MainFoundation
How many valence electrons does the carbon of a singlet carbene carry?
Q11
Single correct
NEETJEE MainFoundation
Free radical chlorination of isobutane occurs fastest at:
Q12
Matrix match
JEE AdvancedExam level
Match each intermediate with its geometry and hybridisation.
Column I: (P) carbocation (Q) carbanion (not conjugated) (R) methyl radical (S) singlet carbene
Column II: (1) sp³, pyramidal (2) sp², planar, 6 e⁻ (3) planar, 7 e⁻ (4) sp², bent, one lone pair
Q13
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Which carbocation is the most stable?
Q14
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Which carbanion is the most stable?
Q15
One or more correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Which of these species can act as electrophiles?
Q16
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Which reaction proceeds through a free radical intermediate?
Q17
Numerical
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
In the free radical monochlorination of propane at 25 °C, a secondary hydrogen is abstracted 3.8 times as fast as a primary hydrogen. What percentage of the monochloro product is 2-chloropropane (nearest whole number)?
Q18
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Cyclobutylmethanol is heated with concentrated HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}. The major alkene formed is:
Q19
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Arrange in decreasing stability: (I) tropylium cation (II) cyclopentadienyl cation (III) benzyl cation (IV) allyl cation
Q20
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Which carbanion is the most stable?
Q21
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
2,3-Dimethylbutane-2,3-diol (pinacol) is warmed with dilute HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}. The main product is:
Q22
One or more correct
JEE AdvancedAdvanced
Which statements are correct?

Ready for the real thing?

Take a timed, NTA style test on this chapter with instant analytics