Organic Chemistry

GOC: Electronic Effects

The four effects that explain almost every reactivity, stability and acidity trend in organic chemistry: inductive, resonance (mesomeric), hyperconjugation and the electromeric effect

NEET style

Ordering groups by −I or +I strength, identifying +R and −R groups from NCERT’s lists, and carbocation stability by hyperconjugation, usually 1 to 2 questions that are often hidden in other chapters

JEE style

Competing effects (−I against +M of halogens, a methoxy group at para against meta), counting hyperconjugative structures, bond lengths from resonance, and dipole moment comparisons

Inductive effect

The inductive effect is the permanent polarisation of a σ bond caused by an electronegative or electropositive atom or group, transmitted along the chain. It fades quickly with distance and is negligible after about three bonds. NCERT names halogens, nitro, cyano, carboxy, ester and aryloxy groups as electron withdrawing, and alkyl groups such as methyl and ethyl as electron donating.

−I (electron withdrawing)

  • −NOX2>−CN>−COOH>−F>−Cl>−Br>−I>−OH>−OCHX3>−CX6HX5\ce{-NO2} > \ce{-CN} > \ce{-COOH} > \ce{-F} > \ce{-Cl} > \ce{-Br} > \ce{-I} > \ce{-OH} > \ce{-OCH3} > \ce{-C6H5}
  • Also −NRX3X+\ce{-NR3+} (strongest)

+I (electron releasing)

  • −O−>−COO−>(CHX3)X3CX−>(CHX3)X2CHX−>CHX3CHX2X−>CHX3X−\ce{-O-} > \ce{-COO-} > \ce{(CH3)3C-} > \ce{(CH3)2CH-} > \ce{CH3CH2-} > \ce{CH3-}
  • Alkyl groups (NCERT) and negatively charged groups such as −O−\ce{-O-} and −COO−\ce{-COO-} (beyond NCERT)

Resonance (mesomeric) effect

When a lone pair or π electrons are in conjugation with a π system, electrons are delocalised. The real molecule is a resonance hybrid of the contributing structures and is more stable than any one of them; its energy difference from the lowest energy contributing structure is the resonance energy. The more important contributing structures there are, the larger the resonance energy, and resonance matters most when the contributors are equivalent (NCERT).

NCERT’s examples: all six C–C bonds of benzene are 139 pm, between C–C (154 pm) and C=C (134 pm), and the two N–O bonds of nitromethane are equal. A resonance energy of about 150 kJ mol−1^{-1} is often quoted for benzene (beyond NCERT).

+R or +M (donate π density)

  • NCERT’s list: halogens, −OH\ce{-OH}, −OR\ce{-OR}, −OCOR\ce{-OCOR}, −NHX2\ce{-NH2}, −NHR\ce{-NHR}, −NRX2\ce{-NR2}, −NHCOR\ce{-NHCOR}
  • Also −O−\ce{-O-} (beyond NCERT’s list)
  • Increase electron density at ortho and para positions

−R or −M (withdraw π density)

  • NCERT’s list: −COOH\ce{-COOH}, −CHO\ce{-CHO}, >C=O\ce{>C=O}, −CN\ce{-CN}, −NOX2\ce{-NO2}
  • Also −COOR\ce{-COOR} and −SOX3H\ce{-SO3H} (beyond NCERT’s list)
  • Decrease electron density at ortho and para positions
  • Only electrons move; the positions of atoms stay the same.
  • All resonance structures must have the same number of unpaired electrons.
  • More stable contributors (NCERT): more covalent bonds, an octet on every atom (a duplet on H), less separation of opposite charges, a negative charge on the more electronegative atom and a positive charge on the more electropositive one, and more dispersal of charge.
  • A conjugated system has alternating single and double bonds, as in buta-1,3-diene, aniline and nitrobenzene; its π electrons are delocalised and the system develops polarity.

Hyperconjugation

Hyperconjugation (no bond resonance) is a general stabilising interaction: the permanent delocalisation of σ electrons of a C–H bond on an α-carbon into an adjacent empty p orbital or π system. NCERT shows it in carbocations, alkenes and alkylarenes. The methyl cation cannot show it, because its empty p orbital is perpendicular to the plane of its C–H bonds.

Number of hyperconjugative structures
number=number of α-hydrogens\text{number} = \text{number of }\alpha\text{-hydrogens}
  • Carbocations: (CHX3)X3CX+\ce{(CH3)3C+} (9 α-H) > (CHX3)X2CHX+\ce{(CH3)2CH+} (6) > CHX3CHX2X+\ce{CH3CH2+} (3) > CHX3X+\ce{CH3+} (0).
  • Alkenes: more alkyl substitution → more α-H → more stable: tetrasubstituted > trisubstituted > disubstituted > monosubstituted. NCERT’s Zaitsev rule (the major alkene carries more alkyl groups on the double bond) fits this; the full order and the link to heats of hydrogenation are beyond NCERT.
  • Explains why toluene’s methyl group is ortho/para directing and slightly activating.
  • Attached to a ring, electron release by hyperconjugation runs CHX3>CHX2CHX3>CH(CHX3)X2>C(CHX3)X3\ce{CH3} > \ce{CH2CH3} > \ce{CH(CH3)2} > \ce{C(CH3)3} (3, 2, 1, 0 α-H), the reverse of the +I order. This Baker Nathan order is beyond NCERT.

Electromeric effect

The electromeric effect (also called the polarisability effect) is the complete, temporary shift of a π electron pair to one atom of a multiple bond at the demand of an attacking reagent. It disappears when the reagent is removed. When the inductive and electromeric effects act in opposite directions, the electromeric effect predominates.

+E

  • π electrons move to the atom to which the attacking reagent attaches
  • For example, HX+\ce{H+} adding to an alkene

−E

  • π electrons move to the atom to which the attacking reagent does not attach
  • For example, CNX−\ce{CN-} adding to a carbonyl carbon (the electrons go to O)
EffectElectrons involvedPermanent?Distance
InductiveσYesShort range, fades fast
Resonanceπ / lone pairYesThroughout the conjugated system
Hyperconjugationσ (C–H) with π / empty pYesAdjacent only
ElectromericπNo (reagent present)Multiple bond only

Formula bank

−I order

−NOX2>−CN>−COOH>−F>−Cl>−Br>−I\ce{-NO2} > \ce{-CN} > \ce{-COOH} > \ce{-F} > \ce{-Cl} > \ce{-Br} > \ce{-I}

The order used in exam practice; NCERT names these groups as electron withdrawing without ranking them

+I order

(CHX3)X3CX−>(CHX3)X2CHX−>CX2HX5X−>CHX3X−\ce{(CH3)3C-} > \ce{(CH3)2CH-} > \ce{C2H5-} > \ce{CH3-}

Hyperconjugative structures

N=number of α-HN = \text{number of } \alpha\text{-H}

Carbocation stability (hyperconjugation)

3∘>2∘>1∘>CHX3X+3^\circ > 2^\circ > 1^\circ > \ce{CH3+}

Alkene stability

RX2C=CRX2>RX2C=CHR>RCH=CHR>RCH=CHX2\ce{R2C=CR2} > \ce{R2C=CHR} > \ce{RCH=CHR} > \ce{RCH=CH2}

Vinyl chloride resonance

CHX2=CH−Cl↔X−X22−CHX2−CH=ClX+\ce{CH2=CH-Cl <-> {}^{-}CH2-CH=Cl+}

Tricks & mnemonics

“NO CN COOH F Cl Br I”

Memorise the −I series as a chant: nitro, cyano, carboxy, fluoro, chloro, bromo, iodo.

Count α-H for hyperconjugation

Carbons next to the cation or double bond: count their hydrogens. More α-H = more stable.

Lone pair next to π = +M

Any atom with a lone pair directly attached to a π system donates by resonance (OH, NH₂, OR, OCOR, X).

π bond to electronegative atom = −M

C=O, C≡N, N=O attached to a π system pull density away.

Resonance beats induction (except halogens)

For −OH\ce{-OH}, −OR\ce{-OR} and −NHX2\ce{-NH2}, +M dominates −I. For halogens, −I dominates +M.

NCERT high yield lines

Original NCERT aligned summaries of the lines examiners love. Tap “Quiz me” to test yourself instantly.

  • The inductive effect is a permanent effect transmitted along a carbon chain, and it decreases rapidly with increasing distance.Class 11 · Unit 8
  • The electromeric effect is a temporary effect that operates only in the presence of an attacking reagent; when it opposes the inductive effect, the electromeric effect wins.Class 11 · Unit 8
  • Hyperconjugation involves delocalisation of σ electrons of a C–H bond of an alkyl group attached to an unsaturated system or to an atom with an unshared p orbital.Class 11 · Unit 8
  • The resonance hybrid is more stable than any of the canonical structures; its energy difference from the lowest energy canonical structure is the resonance energy.Class 11 · Unit 8
  • NCERT lists halogens, OH, OR, OCOR, NH₂, NHR, NR₂ and NHCOR as +R groups, and COOH, CHO, >C=O, CN and NO₂ as −R groups.Class 11 · Unit 8

Solved problems

Example 1
NEETFoundation
Arrange in decreasing −I effect: −Cl\ce{-Cl}, −NOX2\ce{-NO2}, −F\ce{-F}, −CN\ce{-CN}.
  1. ANO₂ > CN > F > Cl
  2. BF > Cl > NO₂ > CN
  3. CCN > NO₂ > F > Cl
  4. DNO₂ > F > CN > Cl
Example 2
NEETJEE MainExam level
Arrange in decreasing stability: 2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene, but-1-ene, (E)-but-2-ene, 2-methylbut-2-ene.
Example 3
JEE MainExam level
Why is the C–Cl bond in chlorobenzene (≈ 169 pm) shorter than in chloromethane (≈ 177 pm)?
Example 4
JEE MainJEE AdvancedExam level
p-Methoxybenzoic acid (pKaK_a 4.47) is weaker than benzoic acid (4.20), but m-methoxybenzoic acid (4.09) is stronger. Explain.

Practice

Q1
Numerical
NEETJEE MainFoundation
Important
How many hyperconjugative structures does the isopropyl cation, (CHX3)X2CHX+\ce{(CH3)2CH+}, have?
Q2
Single correct
NEETJEE MainFoundation
Important
Which alkene is the most stable?
Q3
One or more correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedFoundation
Important
Which groups show a +M effect when attached to benzene?
Q4
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Important
Which acid is the strongest?
Q5
Single correct
NEETJEE MainFoundation
Important
Halogens on a benzene ring are:
Q6
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Which electronic effect is temporary?
Q7
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Which group has the strongest −I effect?
Q8
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Hyperconjugation is also called:
Q9
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Which group shows a −M effect?
Q10
Numerical
JEE MainExam level
How many α-hydrogens (hyperconjugating H) does 2-methylbut-2-ene have?
Q11
Single correct
NEETFoundation
The +I effect is greatest for:
Q12
Matrix match
JEE AdvancedNEETFoundation
Match the effect with its description.
Column I: (P) inductive (Q) resonance (R) hyperconjugation (S) electromeric
Column II: (1) temporary π shift at the demand of a reagent (2) delocalisation of C–H σ electrons into an adjacent π system or empty p orbital (3) permanent σ polarisation fading with distance (4) π or lone pair delocalisation over a conjugated system
Q13
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Arrange in decreasing acid strength: (I) 2-chlorobutanoic acid (II) 3-chlorobutanoic acid (III) 4-chlorobutanoic acid (IV) butanoic acid
Q14
Numerical
NEETJEE MainExam level
How many hyperconjugative structures (α-hydrogens) does the 2-methylbutan-2-yl cation, (CHX3)X2CX+CHX2CHX3\ce{(CH3)2C^+CH2CH3}, have?
Q15
Numerical
NEETJEE MainExam level
What is the C–O bond order in the formate ion, HCOOX−\ce{HCOO-}?
Q16
One or more correct
NEETExam level
Which statements are correct?
Q17
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Which compound undergoes electrophilic substitution fastest?
Q18
Single correct
JEE MainExam level
When attached to a benzene ring, the electron release by hyperconjugation follows the order:
Q19
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Arrange in decreasing acid strength: (I) benzoic acid (II) 4-nitrobenzoic acid (III) 4-methylbenzoic acid (IV) 4-methoxybenzoic acid
Q20
One or more correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Hyperconjugation helps to explain which of these observations?
Q21
Single correct
NEETJEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Which resonance structure of propenal (acrolein), CHX2=CH−CH=O\ce{CH2=CH-CH=O}, contributes least to the hybrid?
Q22
Numerical
NEETJEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
When each group is attached to a benzene ring, how many of them show a +M (+R) effect?
−OH\ce{-OH}, −NOX2\ce{-NO2}, −NHCOCHX3\ce{-NHCOCH3}, −CHO\ce{-CHO}, −Cl\ce{-Cl}, −OCOCHX3\ce{-OCOCH3}, −COOCHX3\ce{-COOCH3}, −N(CHX3)X2\ce{-N(CH3)2}, −CN\ce{-CN}
Q23
Single correct
JEE AdvancedAdvanced
Arrange in decreasing dipole moment: (I) aniline (II) nitrobenzene (III) 4-nitroaniline
Q24
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Arrange the C–O bond lengths in decreasing order: (I) methanol (II) carbonate ion (III) acetate ion (IV) acetone

Ready for the real thing?

Take a timed, NTA style test on this chapter with instant analytics