Organic Chemistry

Carboxylic Acids & Derivatives

Acids, acid chlorides, anhydrides, esters and amides: preparation, acidity, esterification and its mechanism, reduction, decarboxylation, the Hell Volhard Zelinsky reaction and nucleophilic acyl substitution

NEET style

Acidity order of substituted acids, HVZ, reactions with NaHCO₃, esterification, preparation via Grignard + CO₂ and the reactivity order of derivatives

JEE style

Esterification mechanism with isotope labelling, conversions among derivatives, decarboxylation and Kolbe products, and acid strength comparisons involving resonance and the ortho effect

Preparation

FromReagentNote
1° alcohols / aldehydesKMnOX4\ce{KMnO4} or KX2CrX2OX7/HX+\ce{K2Cr2O7/H+}Same number of carbons
AlkylbenzenesHot alkaline KMnOX4\ce{KMnO4}, then HX+\ce{H+} (or chromic acid)Benzoic acid whatever the chain length (needs a benzylic H, so a tert alkyl group is not oxidised)
NitrilesHX3OX+\ce{H3O+}, heat (via amide)RCN→RCOOH\ce{RCN -> RCOOH}
Grignard reagentsDry ice (COX2\ce{CO2}), then HX3OX+\ce{H3O+}Adds one carbon: RMgX→RCOOH\ce{RMgX -> RCOOH}
Acid derivativesHydrolysis (acid or base)Esters, amides, anhydrides, acid chlorides

Acidity

Carboxylic acids (pKaK_a about 4 to 5) are stronger than phenols and alcohols because the carboxylate ion has two equivalent resonance structures with the charge on two oxygen atoms. They liberate COX2\ce{CO2} from NaHCOX3\ce{NaHCO3}, a test that distinguishes them from phenols.

Typical order
CFX3COOH>CClX3COOH>CHClX2COOH>NOX2CHX2COOH>NC−CHX2COOH>FCHX2COOH>ClCHX2COOH>HCOOH>CX6HX5COOH>CHX3COOH\ce{CF3COOH} > \ce{CCl3COOH} > \ce{CHCl2COOH} > \ce{NO2CH2COOH} > \ce{NC-CH2COOH} > \ce{FCH2COOH} > \ce{ClCH2COOH} > \ce{HCOOH} > \ce{C6H5COOH} > \ce{CH3COOH}

Electron withdrawing groups increase acidity; electron donating groups decrease it. Benzoic acid (4.20) is stronger than acetic acid (4.76) because the sp² phenyl carbon is more electronegative than an sp³ carbon.

Ortho effect: almost any ortho substituent (even CHX3\ce{CH3}) makes a benzoic acid stronger than benzoic acid itself, because steric crowding twists the carboxyl group out of the ring plane and cuts off the ring’s electron donation by resonance.

Reactions of carboxylic acids

RCOOH+RX′OH⇌HX+RCOORX′+HX2O\ce{RCOOH + R'OH <=>[H+] RCOOR' + H2O}

Fischer esterification goes by protonation of C=O, attack by the alcohol, proton transfer and loss of water; isotope labelling (18^{18}O in the alcohol ends up in the ester) proves the C–OH bond of the acid breaks

ReagentProduct
PClX5\ce{PCl5}, PClX3\ce{PCl3} or SOClX2\ce{SOCl2}Acid chloride RCOCl (SOClX2\ce{SOCl2} preferred: gaseous byproducts)
NHX3\ce{NH3}, then strong heatingAmmonium salt, then amide RCONHX2\ce{RCONH2}
PX2OX5\ce{P2O5} or heat with conc. HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}Anhydride (RCO)X2O\ce{(RCO)2O}
LiAlHX4\ce{LiAlH4} or BX2HX6\ce{B2H6}1° alcohol (NaBH₄ does not reduce acids)
NaOH + CaO, heat (as sodium salt)Alkane with one carbon fewer (decarboxylation)
Electrolysis of sodium salt (Kolbe)R–R + COX2\ce{CO2} at the anode
RCHX2COOH→HX2OXX2 / red PRCHXCOOH\ce{RCH2COOH ->[X2 / red P][H2O] RCHXCOOH}

Hell Volhard Zelinsky (HVZ) reaction: α-halogenation of acids that have an α-hydrogen

The carboxyl group (−COOH\ce{-COOH}) is deactivating and meta directing in electrophilic substitution; benzoic acid does not undergo Friedel Crafts reactions (the carboxyl group binds AlClX3\ce{AlCl3} and deactivates the ring).

Acid derivatives and nucleophilic acyl substitution

Reactivity towards nucleophiles
RCOCl>(RCO)X2O>RCOORX′>RCONHX2\ce{RCOCl} > \ce{(RCO)2O} > \ce{RCOOR'} > \ce{RCONH2}

Set by leaving group ability (ClX−>RCOOX−>RX′OX−>NHX2X−\ce{Cl-} > \ce{RCOO-} > \ce{R'O-} > \ce{NH2-}) and by how much the leaving group’s lone pair is delocalised into C=O (amide resonance is strongest)

Nucleophilic acyl substitution proceeds by addition followed by elimination through a tetrahedral intermediate. A more reactive derivative can always be converted into a less reactive one, not the reverse.

  • Hydrolysis: all give the acid (amides need prolonged heating with acid or alkali).
  • Alcoholysis: acid chloride or anhydride + alcohol → ester. Ester + alcohol → new ester (transesterification).
  • Aminolysis: acid chloride, anhydride or ester + NHX3\ce{NH3} or amine → amide.
  • Amide + BrX2\ce{Br2}/NaOH → amine with one carbon fewer (Hofmann bromamide degradation).

Formula bank

Grignard + CO₂

RMgX+COX2→HX3OX+RCOOH\ce{RMgX + CO2 ->[H3O+] RCOOH}

Nitrile hydrolysis

RCN+2 HX2O+HX+→RCOOH+NHX4X+\ce{RCN + 2H2O + H+ -> RCOOH + NH4+}

Esterification

RCOOH+RX′OH⇌HX+RCOORX′+HX2O\ce{RCOOH + R'OH <=>[H+] RCOOR' + H2O}

Acid chloride

RCOOH+SOClX2→RCOCl+SOX2+HCl\ce{RCOOH + SOCl2 -> RCOCl + SO2 + HCl}

HVZ reaction

CHX3COOH+ClX2→red PClCHX2COOH+HCl\ce{CH3COOH + Cl2 ->[red P] ClCH2COOH + HCl}

Decarboxylation

RCOONa+NaOH→CaORH+NaX2COX3\ce{RCOONa + NaOH ->[CaO] RH + Na2CO3}

Reduction

RCOOH→LiAlHX4RCHX2OH\ce{RCOOH ->[LiAlH4] RCH2OH}

Derivative reactivity

RCOCl>(RCO)X2O>RCOORX′>RCONHX2\ce{RCOCl} > \ce{(RCO)2O} > \ce{RCOOR'} > \ce{RCONH2}

Bicarbonate test

RCOOH+NaHCOX3→RCOONa+HX2O+COX2↑\ce{RCOOH + NaHCO3 -> RCOONa + H2O + CO2 ^}

Tricks & mnemonics

Carbon count map

Grignard + CO₂: +1 C. Nitrile hydrolysis: same C as nitrile. Decarboxylation: −1 C. Kolbe: 2R. Hofmann bromamide: −1 C.

“Cl > An > E > Am”

Acid Cloride > Anhydride > Ester > Amide: the order of reactivity towards nucleophiles.

Fizz test

NaHCO₃ effervescence = carboxylic acid (or a very strong phenol such as picric acid).

NaBH₄ is too gentle

NaBH₄ reduces aldehydes and ketones but not acids or esters. LiAlH₄ reduces all of them.

HVZ needs an α-H

No α-hydrogen (for example benzoic acid or (CH₃)₃CCOOH) → no HVZ.

NCERT high yield lines

Original NCERT aligned summaries of the lines examiners love. Tap “Quiz me” to test yourself instantly.

  • Carboxylic acids react with sodium bicarbonate to evolve carbon dioxide; phenols do not.Class 12 · Unit 8
  • Carboxylic acids having an α-hydrogen are halogenated at the α-position on treatment with chlorine or bromine in the presence of a little red phosphorus (Hell Volhard Zelinsky reaction).Class 12 · Unit 8
  • Electron withdrawing groups increase the acidity of carboxylic acids by stabilising the conjugate base; electron donating groups decrease it.Class 12 · Unit 8
  • Carboxylic acids are reduced to primary alcohols by lithium aluminium hydride or diborane; diborane does not easily reduce ester, nitro or halo groups.Class 12 · Unit 8

Solved problems

Example 1
NEETFoundation
What is formed when CHX3MgBr\ce{CH3MgBr} reacts with dry ice and the product is hydrolysed?
  1. AMethanol
  2. BAcetic acid
  3. CAcetone
  4. DFormic acid
Example 2
JEE MainJEE AdvancedExam level
Acetic acid is esterified with methanol labelled with 18^{18}O (CHX3−X18X2218OH\ce{CH3-^{18}OH}). Where does the label end up, and what does this prove?
Example 3
NEETFoundation
Arrange in decreasing reactivity towards hydrolysis: acetamide, acetyl chloride, ethyl acetate, acetic anhydride.
Example 4
NEETJEE MainFoundation
How would you distinguish benzoic acid from phenol by a chemical test?

Practice

Q1
One or more correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedExam level
Important
Which statements about Fischer esterification are correct?
Q2
Matrix match
NEETJEE AdvancedFoundation
Important
Match the conversion with the reagent.
Column I: (P) RCOOH → RCOCl (Q) RCOOH → RCH₂OH (R) RCH₂COOH → RCHClCOOH (S) RMgX → RCOOH
Column II: (1) Cl₂/red P (2) CO₂ then H₃O⁺ (3) SOCl₂ (4) LiAlH₄
Q3
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Important
The correct order of acid strength is:
(I) CHX3COOH\ce{CH3COOH} (II) ClCHX2COOH\ce{ClCH2COOH} (III) FCHX2COOH\ce{FCH2COOH} (IV) ClX2CHCOOH\ce{Cl2CHCOOH}
Q4
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Important
Arrange in decreasing order of acid strength: o-toluic acid (I), m-toluic acid (II), p-toluic acid (III) and benzoic acid (IV).
Q5
Matrix match
NEETJEE MainExam level
Important
Match each reaction with its organic product.
Column I: (P) CHX3CHX2COONa\ce{CH3CH2COONa}, NaOH/CaO, heat (Q) aqueous CHX3CHX2COONa\ce{CH3CH2COONa}, electrolysis (R) CHX3CHX2COOH\ce{CH3CH2COOH}, ClX2\ce{Cl2}/red P, then HX2O\ce{H2O} (S) CHX3CHX2CONHX2\ce{CH3CH2CONH2}, BrX2\ce{Br2}/NaOH
Column II: (1) CHX3CHX2NHX2\ce{CH3CH2NH2} (2) CHX3CHClCOOH\ce{CH3CHClCOOH} (3) CHX3CHX3\ce{CH3CH3} (4) CHX3CHX2CHX2CHX3\ce{CH3CH2CH2CH3}
Q6
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Which is the strongest acid?
Q7
Single correct
NEETFoundation
The HVZ reaction requires:
Q8
Single correct
NEETJEE MainFoundation
Which reagent does NOT reduce a carboxylic acid to an alcohol?
Q9
Single correct
NEETFoundation
The most reactive acid derivative towards nucleophiles is:
Q10
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Sodium propanoate heated with soda lime gives:
Q11
Single correct
NEETFoundation
The best reagent for converting acetic acid to acetyl chloride is:
Q12
Single correct
NEETFoundation
The carboxyl group (−COOH\ce{-COOH}) on a benzene ring is:
Q13
Numerical
NEETJEE MainFoundation
How many carbon atoms are in the acid formed when n-butylmagnesium bromide reacts with CO₂ followed by hydrolysis?
Q14
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Which reacts with NaHCO₃ to release CO₂?
Q15
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Methyl cyanide on acid hydrolysis gives:
Q16
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
The correct order of acid strength of 2-chlorobutanoic acid (I), 3-chlorobutanoic acid (II), 4-chlorobutanoic acid (III) and butanoic acid (IV) is:
Q17
Numerical
NEETJEE MainExam level
An aqueous solution of sodium propanoate is electrolysed (Kolbe electrolysis). How many carbon atoms does the hydrocarbon formed at the anode contain?
Q18
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Propanoic acid is treated with BrX2\ce{Br2} and a little red phosphorus, then with water, to give A. A is heated with excess aqueous ammonia and the mixture is acidified carefully to the isoelectric point to give B. B is:
Q19
Numerical
NEETJEE MainExam level
0.458 g of the silver salt of a monobasic carboxylic acid leaves 0.216 g of metallic silver on ignition. Find the molar mass of the acid in g/mol (Ag = 108, H = 1).
Q20
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Methyl benzoate is hydrolysed by heating with NaOH dissolved in HX2X18X2218O\ce{H2^{18}O}, and the mixture is then acidified. Where is the 18^{18}O label found?
Q21
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
The correct order of the rate of alkaline hydrolysis (saponification) of the methyl esters of the following acids is:
(I) 4-nitrobenzoic acid (II) benzoic acid (III) 4-methylbenzoic acid (IV) 4-methoxybenzoic acid
Q22
Single correct
JEE AdvancedAdvanced
Which acid loses COX2\ce{CO2} most readily when heated gently (around 100 °C)?
Q23
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Which dicarboxylic acid forms a cyclic anhydride directly, by intramolecular loss of water, when heated?
Q24
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Under identical conditions, the rate of acid catalysed esterification with methanol follows the order:

Ready for the real thing?

Take a timed, NTA style test on this chapter with instant analytics