Organic Chemistry

Acidity, Basicity & Aromaticity

Compare any two organic acids or bases in seconds by looking at the stability of the conjugate species, and decide aromatic, antiaromatic or nonaromatic with Hückel’s rule

NEET style

Ordering substituted carboxylic acids, phenols and amines by strength, NCERT pKaK_a and pKbK_b tables, and identifying aromatic compounds

JEE style

Competing effects (ortho effect, steric inhibition of resonance, solvation in amines), aromatic and antiaromatic ions and heterocycles, and the acidity of hydrocarbons

What makes an acid strong

An acid is strong if its conjugate base is stable. Anything that spreads out or stabilises the negative charge increases acidity:

  • Electronegativity of the atom bearing the charge (same period): CHX4<NHX3<HX2O<HF\ce{CH4} < \ce{NH3} < \ce{H2O} < \ce{HF}.
  • Size of the atom (same group): HF < HCl < HBr < HI in water, because larger anions spread charge better.
  • Hybridisation: sp > sp² > sp³ (ethyne > ethene > ethane).
  • Resonance: carboxylate (two equivalent O) > phenoxide (charge partly on ring) > alkoxide (localised).
  • Inductive effect: −I groups near the acidic site increase acidity; +I groups decrease it.
Overall order
RCOOH>HX2COX3>CX6HX5OH>HX2O>ROH>HC≡CH>NHX3>RH\ce{RCOOH} > \ce{H2CO3} > \ce{C6H5OH} > \ce{H2O} > \ce{ROH} > \ce{HC#CH} > \ce{NH3} > \ce{RH}

Carboxylic acids and phenols

NCERT gives the values for CF₃COOH, benzoic acid and acetic acid; the others are standard data that follow NCERT’s order
AcidpKaK_aReason
CFX3COOH\ce{CF3COOH}0.23Three strongly −I F atoms; NCERT calls it the strongest organic acid
ClX3CCOOH\ce{Cl3CCOOH}0.7Three −I Cl
ClX2CHCOOH\ce{Cl2CHCOOH}1.3Two −I Cl
ClCHX2COOH\ce{ClCH2COOH}2.9One −I Cl
HCOOH\ce{HCOOH}3.75No +I alkyl group
CX6HX5COOH\ce{C6H5COOH}4.19sp² carbon is more electronegative (NCERT)
CHX3COOH\ce{CH3COOH}4.76+I of CH₃
CHX3CHX2COOH\ce{CH3CH2COOH}4.87Stronger +I

Haloacid strength falls with distance from COOH (2-chloro > 3-chloro > 4-chlorobutanoic acid) and with decreasing electronegativity (F > Cl > Br > I). NCERT ranks substituents by how much they raise acidity, Ph < I < Br < Cl < F < CN < NO₂ < CF₃, and gives the order CF₃COOH > CCl₃COOH > CHCl₂COOH > O₂NCH₂COOH > NCCH₂COOH > FCH₂COOH > ClCH₂COOH > BrCH₂COOH > HCOOH > ClCH₂CH₂COOH > C₆H₅COOH > C₆H₅CH₂COOH > CH₃COOH > CH₃CH₂COOH. A phenyl or vinyl group attached directly to COOH raises acidity because its sp² carbon is more electronegative.

Values from NCERT’s table, except picric acid, which NCERT only ranks as the most acidic
PhenolpKaK_a
2,4,6-Trinitrophenol (picric acid)< 1
4-Nitrophenol7.1
2-Nitrophenol7.2
3-Nitrophenol8.3
Phenol10.0
4-Methylphenol (p-cresol)10.2
Ethanol (for comparison)15.9

Electron withdrawing groups such as −NOX2\ce{-NO2} raise acidity, more strongly from the ortho and para positions, where the phenoxide charge can spread onto them (−M); at meta only −I acts (NCERT). Electron releasing alkyl groups lower acidity, so the cresols are weaker acids than phenol. From these values phenol is about a million times more acidic than ethanol.

Basicity of amines

A base is strong if its lone pair is available and its conjugate acid is stable (well solvated).

All values from NCERT (ammonia from its text)
AminepKbK_b (water)
(CX2HX5)X2NH\ce{(C2H5)2NH}3.00
(CX2HX5)X3N\ce{(C2H5)3N}3.25
(CHX3)X2NH\ce{(CH3)2NH}3.27
CX2HX5NHX2\ce{C2H5NH2}3.29
CHX3NHX2\ce{CH3NH2}3.38
(CHX3)X3N\ce{(CH3)3N}4.22
CX6HX5CHX2NHX2\ce{C6H5CH2NH2} (benzylamine)4.70
NHX3\ce{NH3}4.75
CX6HX5N(CHX3)X2\ce{C6H5N(CH3)2}8.92
CX6HX5NHCHX3\ce{C6H5NHCH3}9.30
CX6HX5NHX2\ce{C6H5NH2} (aniline)9.38

In water, basicity balances the +I effect, hydrogen bond solvation of the ammonium ion and steric hindrance: methyl series 2° > 1° > 3° > NHX3\ce{NH3}; ethyl series 2° > 3° > 1° > NHX3\ce{NH3}. In the gas phase (no solvation) the order is simply 3° > 2° > 1° > NHX3\ce{NH3}.

Aryl amines are much weaker bases: the lone pair is in conjugation with the ring, and NCERT notes that aniline is a resonance hybrid of five structures while the anilinium ion has only two, so protonation costs aniline stability. Electron releasing groups such as −OCHX3\ce{-OCH3} and −CHX3\ce{-CH3} increase basicity (p-toluidine > aniline); electron withdrawing groups such as −NOX2\ce{-NO2}, −SOX3H\ce{-SO3H}, −COOH\ce{-COOH} and halogens decrease it (aniline > p-nitroaniline).

Beyond NCERT: amides are almost neutral, and guanidine is one of the strongest neutral organic bases (its conjugate acid is resonance stabilised over three equivalent N atoms).

Aromaticity: Hückel’s rule

  1. 1
    A planar ring (or nearly planar).
  2. 2
    Complete delocalisation of the π electrons over the ring: every ring atom has a p orbital (sp², or a lone pair in a p orbital).
  3. 3
    (4n+2)(4n + 2) π electrons in the ring, with nn = 0, 1, 2… (2, 6, 10, 14): Hückel’s rule. These are NCERT’s three conditions.
ClassConditionExamples
AromaticAll three conditions, (4n+2)π(4n+2)\piNCERT: benzene, cyclopentadienyl anion and cycloheptatrienyl (tropylium) cation (6π), naphthalene (10π), anthracene and phenanthrene (14π), and the heterocycles pyridine, furan and thiophene; also pyrrole and the cyclopropenyl cation (2π)
Antiaromatic (beyond NCERT)Cyclic, planar, conjugated, 4n π4n\,\piCyclobutadiene, cyclopentadienyl cation, cyclopropenyl anion
Nonaromatic (beyond NCERT)Fails planarity or full conjugationCyclooctatetraene (tub shaped), cycloheptatriene (sp³ CH₂), cyclohexa-1,3-diene

Formula bank

Hückel’s rule

π electrons=4n+2\pi\ \text{electrons} = 4n + 2

Antiaromatic (beyond NCERT)

π electrons=4n (cyclic, planar, conjugated)\pi\ \text{electrons} = 4n\ (\text{cyclic, planar, conjugated})

Acid strength scale

pKa=−log⁡Ka\text{p}K_a = -\log K_a

Haloacid strength

FCHX2COOH>ClCHX2COOH>BrCHX2COOH>ICHX2COOH\ce{FCH2COOH} > \ce{ClCH2COOH} > \ce{BrCH2COOH} > \ce{ICH2COOH}

Methylamines in water

(CHX3)X2NH>CHX3NHX2>(CHX3)X3N>NHX3\ce{(CH3)2NH} > \ce{CH3NH2} > \ce{(CH3)3N} > \ce{NH3}

Ethylamines in water

(CX2HX5)X2NH>(CX2HX5)X3N>CX2HX5NHX2>NHX3\ce{(C2H5)2NH} > \ce{(C2H5)3N} > \ce{C2H5NH2} > \ce{NH3}

Nitrophenols

p-NOX2>o-NOX2>m-NOX2>CX6HX5OHp\text{-}\ce{NO2} > o\text{-}\ce{NO2} > m\text{-}\ce{NO2} > \ce{C6H5OH}

Tricks & mnemonics

Look at the conjugate

Acid strength = stability of the anion formed. Base strength = availability of the lone pair (and stability of the cation formed).

Methyl “2, 1, 3”, ethyl “2, 3, 1”

Aqueous basicity: methylamines 2° > 1° > 3°; ethylamines 2° > 3° > 1°. NH₃ is last in both.

Ortho almost always wins

Almost any ortho substituted benzoic acid > benzoic acid. Memorise it as an exception to normal electronic reasoning. (The ortho effect is beyond NCERT.)

Count π electrons on ions

Count 2 π electrons for each ring C=C, then add 2 for a carbanion carbon (lone pair in a p orbital) and 0 for a carbocation carbon (empty p orbital). Cyclopentadienyl: two C=C give 4π, so the anion has 6π (aromatic) and the cation 4π (antiaromatic, a term beyond NCERT).

Lone pair inside the ring?

If a heteroatom’s lone pair is needed for 6π (pyrrole, furan), it is not available, so the compound is a weak base. If it is not needed (pyridine), it is basic. (Beyond NCERT.)

NCERT high yield lines

Original NCERT aligned summaries of the lines examiners love. Tap “Quiz me” to test yourself instantly.

  • Phenol is more acidic than ethanol because the phenoxide ion is stabilised by resonance, while ethoxide is not.Class 12 · Unit 7
  • Electron withdrawing groups increase the acidity of carboxylic acids; electron donating groups decrease it.Class 12 · Unit 8
  • In aqueous solution, the basic strength of methyl substituted amines is (CH₃)₂NH > CH₃NH₂ > (CH₃)₃N > NH₃, due to inductive, solvation and steric effects.Class 12 · Unit 9
  • Aniline is a weaker base than ammonia because the lone pair on nitrogen is delocalised over the benzene ring.Class 12 · Unit 9
  • NCERT’s conditions for aromaticity are planarity, complete delocalisation of the π electrons in the ring and (4n+2)(4n+2) π electrons (Hückel rule): benzene, the cyclopentadienyl anion and the cycloheptatrienyl cation have 6, naphthalene 10, and anthracene and phenanthrene 14.Class 11 · Unit 9
  • Carboxylic acids are stronger than phenols because the carboxylate ion is stabilised by two equivalent resonance structures with the charge on oxygen, while the phenoxide ion has nonequivalent structures that put the charge on less electronegative carbon.Class 12 · Unit 8

Solved problems

Example 1
NEETFoundation
Arrange in decreasing acidity: CHX3COOH\ce{CH3COOH}, ClCHX2COOH\ce{ClCH2COOH}, ClX2CHCOOH\ce{Cl2CHCOOH}, ClX3CCOOH\ce{Cl3CCOOH}.
  1. ACl₃C > Cl₂CH > ClCH₂ > CH₃
  2. BCH₃ > ClCH₂ > Cl₂CH > Cl₃C
  3. CClCH₂ > Cl₂CH > Cl₃C > CH₃
  4. Dall equal
Example 2
NEETJEE MainExam level
Arrange phenol, o-, m- and p-nitrophenol in decreasing acidity.
Example 3
NEETJEE MainExam level
Arrange in decreasing basicity in water: NHX3\ce{NH3}, CHX3NHX2\ce{CH3NH2}, (CHX3)X2NH\ce{(CH3)2NH}, (CHX3)X3N\ce{(CH3)3N}, CX6HX5NHX2\ce{C6H5NH2}.
Example 4
JEE MainJEE AdvancedExam level
Classify as aromatic, antiaromatic or nonaromatic: cyclobutadiene, cyclooctatetraene, tropylium cation, pyrrole.
Example 5
JEE AdvancedExam level
Why is o-toluic acid (2-methylbenzoic acid, pKaK_a 3.9) stronger than benzoic acid (4.19 in NCERT), although CH₃ is electron donating?

Practice

Q1
Single correct
NEETJEE MainFoundation
Important
Which is aromatic?
Q2
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Important
The correct order of basic strength in water is:
Q3
One or more correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedExam level
Important
Which are stronger acids than benzoic acid?
Q4
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Important
Which phenol is the most acidic?
Q5
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Important
The correct order of basic strength of ethylamines in water is:
Q6
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Which is the strongest acid?
Q7
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Which is the weakest base?
Q8
Numerical
NEETJEE MainFoundation
How many π electrons does the naphthalene ring system contain?
Q9
Single correct
NEETFoundation
Which is the strongest acid?
Q10
Single correct
JEE MainExam level
Pyrrole is a much weaker base than pyridine because:
Q11
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedExam level
Cyclooctatetraene is:
Q12
Numerical
NEETJEE MainFoundation
How many π electrons does the tropylium cation (CX7HX7X+\ce{C7H7+}) have?
Q13
Matrix match
JEE AdvancedExam level
Match each species with its classification.
Column I: (P) benzene (Q) cyclobutadiene (R) cycloheptatriene (S) cyclopropenyl cation
Column II: (1) aromatic, 2π (2) antiaromatic (3) nonaromatic (4) aromatic, 6π
Q14
Single correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Arrange in decreasing acid strength: (I) phenol (II) 4-methylphenol (III) 4-nitrophenol (IV) 3-nitrophenol
Q15
One or more correct
NEETJEE MainExam level
Which of these are aromatic?
Q16
Single correct
JEE MainExam level
Which hydrocarbon is the most acidic?
Q17
Numerical
NEETJEE MainExam level
The pKaK_a of chloroacetic acid is 2.86 and that of acetic acid is 4.76. By what factor is the KaK_a of chloroacetic acid larger (nearest whole number)?
Q18
Numerical
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
How many of the following are aromatic?
benzene, pyridine, pyrrole, cyclobutadiene, cyclooctatetraene, tropylium cation, cyclopentadienyl anion, cyclopentadienyl cation, cycloheptatriene, naphthalene
Q19
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Arrange in decreasing basic strength: (I) aniline (II) 4-methylaniline (III) 4-methoxyaniline (IV) 4-nitroaniline
Q20
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Arrange in decreasing acid strength: (I) benzoic acid (II) 2-methylbenzoic acid (III) 3-methylbenzoic acid (IV) 4-methylbenzoic acid
Q21
Single correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Arrange in decreasing basic strength: (I) piperidine (II) pyridine (III) aniline (IV) pyrrole
Q22
One or more correct
JEE MainJEE AdvancedAdvanced
Which statements are correct?
Q23
Single correct
JEE AdvancedAdvanced
Which species is antiaromatic?

Ready for the real thing?

Take a timed, NTA style test on this chapter with instant analytics