Exception Tracker

147 exceptions examiners love, each with the reason. Turn on self test to hide the reasons until you have recalled them.

147 of 147 exceptions

Open chapter ›
  • ΔiH1\Delta_iH_1: Be > B and Mg > Al.

    s electrons penetrate more than p electrons, so the first p electron is easier to remove.

  • ΔiH1\Delta_iH_1: N > O and P > S.

    Half filled p³ stability; pairing repulsion in p⁴.

  • Atomic radius of Ga (135 pm) is smaller than Al (143 pm).

    Ten poorly shielding 3d electrons increase ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} for Ga.

  • Zr and Hf have almost identical atomic radii (160 and 159 pm).

    Lanthanoid contraction cancels the expected increase.

  • Cl has the most negative electron gain enthalpy, not F.

    Interelectronic repulsion in the small 2p shell of F.

  • O has a less negative electron gain enthalpy than S.

    Small size of O; repulsion in the compact 2p shell.

  • Noble gases, Be, Mg and N have positive or near zero electron gain enthalpies.

    Stable closed or half filled configurations.

  • Noble gases appear larger than the halogens before them.

    Their radii are van der Waals radii, while others are covalent radii.

  • ΔiH1\Delta_iH_1 of Pb (715 kJ/mol) is higher than that of Sn (708 kJ/mol).

    Poor shielding by 4f and 5d electrons (lanthanoid contraction).

  • ΔiH1\Delta_iH_1 of Ga (579 kJ/mol) is slightly higher than that of Al (577 kJ/mol), not lower.

    Extra nuclear charge is poorly shielded by 3d electrons.

  • ΔiH2\Delta_iH_2 of O (3388 kJ/mol) is higher than that of F (3374 kJ/mol).

    OX+\ce{O+} has the half filled 2p32p^3 set, while FX+\ce{F+} is 2p42p^4.

Hydrogen & the s-Block Elements

Open chapter ›
  • Li is the strongest reducing agent in water even though it has the highest ionisation enthalpy in group 1.

    Very high hydration enthalpy of Li⁺.

  • Li is the only alkali metal that forms a nitride directly (LiX3N\ce{Li3N}).

    Small Li⁺ gives a high lattice energy with N³⁻; diagonal similarity with Mg.

  • LiX2COX3\ce{Li2CO3} decomposes on heating; other alkali metal carbonates do not.

    Small Li⁺ polarises the carbonate ion.

  • LiNOX3\ce{LiNO3} gives NOX2\ce{NO2} on heating, while NaNOX3\ce{NaNO3} gives NaNOX2\ce{NaNO2} and OX2\ce{O2}.

    Li⁺ stabilises the small oxide ion.

  • LiX+\ce{Li+} has the lowest ionic mobility in water despite being the smallest ion.

    It is the most heavily hydrated.

  • BeO and Be(OH)X2\ce{Be(OH)2} are amphoteric; the other group 2 oxides are basic.

    High charge density of Be²⁺ (similar to Al³⁺).

  • BeClX2\ce{BeCl2} is a polymeric chain in the solid state.

    Electron deficient Be completes its octet through Cl bridges.

  • Be and Mg give no flame colour.

    Their electrons are too tightly held to be excited by the flame.

  • Solubility of group 2 sulfates decreases down the group, while that of hydroxides increases.

    Hydration enthalpy dominates for sulfates; lattice enthalpy for hydroxides.

  • K, Rb and Cs form superoxides; Na forms a peroxide; Li forms a normal oxide.

    Lattice stabilisation of large anions by large cations.

Group 13: The Boron Family

Open chapter ›
  • Atomic radius of Ga (135 pm) is less than that of Al (143 pm).

    Poor shielding by the ten 3d electrons.

  • First IE order is B > Tl > Ga > Al > In, so Tl is higher than Al and In.

    Poor shielding by 4f and 5d electrons raises ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} for Tl.

  • Lewis acidity: BFX3<BClX3<BBrX3<BIX3\ce{BF3 < BCl3 < BBr3 < BI3}.

    Back bonding between filled p orbitals of the halogen and the empty 2p orbital of B is strongest from F.

  • TlX+\ce{Tl+} is more stable than TlX3+\ce{Tl^3+}.

    Inert pair effect.

  • TlIX3\ce{TlI3} is thallium(I) triiodide, TlX+[IX3]X−\ce{Tl+[I3]-}, not thallium(III) iodide.

    Tl³⁺ would oxidise I⁻; E°(Tl³⁺/Tl⁺) = +1.25 V vs E°(I₃⁻/I⁻) = +0.54 V.

  • Boric acid is a Lewis acid, not a proton donor.

    Electron deficient B accepts OH⁻.

  • Gallium melts at 303 K but boils at 2676 K.

    Unusual structure of Ga₂ units in the solid; strong metallic bonding in the liquid.

  • Al is rendered passive by concentrated HNOX3\ce{HNO3}.

    A protective Al₂O₃ film forms.

  • Electronegativity increases from Al (1.5) to Tl (1.8).

    Poor shielding by d and f electrons keeps the heavier atoms smaller than expected.

  • BClX3\ce{BCl3} is monomeric while AlClX3\ce{AlCl3} dimerises.

    Small B is partly satisfied by back bonding and cannot hold four large Cl atoms; Al can.

  • [BFX6]X3−\ce{[BF6]^3-} does not exist, although [AlFX6]X3−\ce{[AlF6]^3-} (cryolite) does.

    Boron has no d orbitals, so its covalency stops at 4.

Group 14: The Carbon Family

Open chapter ›
  • Lead shows practically no catenation, while carbon shows the most.

    E–E bond enthalpy falls sharply down the group.

  • PbIX4\ce{PbI4} and PbBrX4\ce{PbBr4} do not exist (or are very unstable).

    Pb(IV) oxidises I⁻ and Br⁻; inert pair effect.

  • CClX4\ce{CCl4} is not hydrolysed, but SiClX4\ce{SiCl4} hydrolyses readily.

    Si can accept the water lone pair into vacant 3d orbitals; C cannot.

  • COX2\ce{CO2} is a gas while SiOX2\ce{SiO2} is a high melting solid.

    C forms double bonds by sideways p orbital overlap (discrete molecules); Si forms a network of single bonds.

  • [SiFX6]X2−\ce{[SiF6]^2-} exists but [SiClX6]X2−\ce{[SiCl6]^2-} does not.

    Six large Cl atoms cannot fit around Si, and the lone pairs of Cl interact only weakly with Si⁴⁺.

  • Diamond does not conduct electricity but is one of the best conductors of heat.

    No free electrons, but the rigid lattice transmits vibrations very efficiently.

  • Graphite, not diamond, is the thermodynamically stable form (ΔfH∘\Delta_fH^\circ of diamond = +1.9 kJ mol−1^{-1}).

    Diamond persists only because conversion is extremely slow.

  • Sn(IV) is more stable than Sn(II), but Pb(II) is more stable than Pb(IV).

    Inert pair effect is stronger for Pb.

  • First IE of Pb (715) is higher than that of Sn (708 kJ mol−1^{-1}).

    Poor shielding by 4f and 5d electrons.

  • CO is a neutral oxide, unlike the acidic COX2\ce{CO2}.

    It does not react with water, acids or bases to form salts.

  • GeO is acidic, while SnO and PbO are amphoteric.

    Metallic character of the element rises down the group.

  • White tin crumbles to grey tin below 286 K (tin pest).

    Grey α-tin is the stable allotrope at low temperature.

Group 15: The Nitrogen Family

Open chapter ›
  • NClX5\ce{NCl5} does not exist although PClX5\ce{PCl5} does.

    N has no d orbitals; maximum covalency 4.

  • Nitrogen is a diatomic gas; phosphorus is a PX4\ce{P4} solid.

    Only N forms strong multiple bonds by sideways p orbital overlap.

  • The N–N single bond is weaker than the P–P single bond.

    Lone pair repulsion across the short N–N bond.

  • NHX3\ce{NH3} boils higher than PHX3\ce{PH3} and AsHX3\ce{AsH3}, yet lower than SbHX3\ce{SbH3} and BiHX3\ce{BiH3}.

    Hydrogen bonding vs increasing van der Waals forces.

  • Bond angle drops sharply from 107.8° (NHX3\ce{NH3}) to 93.6° (PHX3\ce{PH3}).

    Larger P uses almost pure p orbitals for bonding (Drago’s rule).

  • HX3POX3\ce{H3PO3} is dibasic and HX3POX2\ce{H3PO2} is monobasic, though each has three H atoms.

    P–H hydrogens are not ionisable.

  • Bi(V) is a strong oxidising agent (NaBiOX3\ce{NaBiO3}).

    Inert pair effect makes Bi(III) more stable.

  • Solid PClX5\ce{PCl5} is ionic, [PClX4]X+[PClX6]X−\ce{[PCl4]+[PCl6]-}.

    Ion pair packs more efficiently in the crystal.

  • PHX3\ce{PH3} is a much weaker base than NHX3\ce{NH3}.

    P’s lone pair is in a diffuse orbital with high s character.

  • Nitrogen has a near zero (slightly positive) electron gain enthalpy.

    Extra stability of the half filled 2p³ configuration and small size.

Group 16: The Oxygen Family

Open chapter ›
  • Oxygen is a diatomic gas, while sulfur is an SX8\ce{S8} solid.

    O forms strong double bonds by sideways p orbital overlap; S prefers rings of single bonds.

  • Water is a liquid with a far higher boiling point than HX2S\ce{H2S}, HX2Se\ce{H2Se} and HX2Te\ce{H2Te}.

    Extensive hydrogen bonding.

  • O has a less negative electron gain enthalpy than S.

    Repulsion in the compact 2p shell.

  • Oxygen shows positive oxidation states only in fluorides (OFX2\ce{OF2} +2, OX2FX2\ce{O2F2} +1).

    Only F is more electronegative.

  • SFX6\ce{SF6} exists and is very inert; OFX6\ce{OF6} and SClX6\ce{SCl6} do not exist.

    No d orbitals for O; steric crowding for six Cl.

  • Bond angle in HX2O\ce{H2O} (104.5°) is much larger than in HX2S\ce{H2S} (92°).

    Drago’s rule: heavier atoms use nearly pure p orbitals.

  • Acid strength: HX2Te>HX2Se>HX2S>HX2O\ce{H2Te > H2Se > H2S > H2O}, opposite to electronegativity.

    Bond enthalpy decreases down the group.

  • SOX3\ce{SO3} is absorbed in sulfuric acid, not in water.

    Direct absorption forms a dense mist of acid droplets.

  • Formation of ozone from oxygen is endothermic.

    O₃ is less stable than O₂.

  • Sulfur vapour at high temperature is paramagnetic.

    It contains S₂ molecules, which, like O₂, have two unpaired electrons.

Group 17: The Halogens

Open chapter ›
  • F–F bond enthalpy (158.8) is lower than Cl–Cl (242.6) and Br–Br (192.8 kJ mol−1^{-1}).

    Lone pair repulsion between small F atoms.

  • Chlorine, not fluorine, has the most negative electron gain enthalpy.

    Compact 2p shell of F repels the incoming electron.

  • F₂ is the strongest oxidant despite its smaller electron gain enthalpy.

    Low bond enthalpy and very high hydration enthalpy of F⁻.

  • Fluorine shows only the −1 oxidation state.

    Most electronegative element; no d orbitals.

  • HF is a weak acid, while HCl, HBr and HI are strong.

    Very strong H–F bond and hydrogen bonding.

  • HF has the highest boiling point of the hydrogen halides.

    Hydrogen bonded chains.

  • AgF is soluble in water; AgCl, AgBr and AgI are insoluble.

    High hydration enthalpy of the small F⁻ ion.

  • CaFX2\ce{CaF2} is insoluble, while CaClX2\ce{CaCl2} is very soluble.

    Very high lattice enthalpy of CaF₂.

  • Fluorine forms only one oxoacid (HOF).

    High electronegativity and small size.

  • HOCl is the strongest oxidant but the weakest acid among chlorine oxoacids.

    Least stabilised conjugate base; unstable +1 chlorine.

  • Interhalogens are more reactive than the parent halogens (except F₂).

    X–X′ bonds are weaker than X–X bonds.

Group 18: The Noble Gases

Open chapter ›
  • Helium is in group 18 though its configuration is 1s21s^2, not ns2np6ns^2np^6.

    Completely filled valence shell and inertness.

  • Helium does not solidify at normal pressure.

    Extremely weak interatomic forces and large zero point energy.

  • Xenon forms stable compounds, while He, Ne and Ar form none under ordinary conditions.

    Lower ionisation enthalpy and larger, more polarisable atom.

  • Hydrolysis of XeFX6\ce{XeF6} is not a redox reaction, though that of XeFX2\ce{XeF2} and XeFX4\ce{XeF4} is.

    Xe remains +6 in XeO₃.

  • XeFX4\ce{XeF4} is square planar despite having six electron pairs.

    Two lone pairs occupy opposite (trans) octahedral positions.

  • Argon, not helium, is the most abundant noble gas in air.

    Ar comes from decay of ⁴⁰K in rocks; light He escapes the atmosphere.

  • The first IE of Xe (1170) is almost equal to that of the OX2\ce{O2} molecule (1175 kJ mol−1^{-1}).

    Basis of Bartlett’s synthesis.

  • Noble gases have positive electron gain enthalpies.

    An added electron must enter a new, higher shell.

The d and f Block Elements

Open chapter ›
  • Cr is 3d54s13d^54s^1 and Cu is 3d104s13d^{10}4s^1.

    Extra exchange stability of half filled and completely filled d subshells.

  • Zn, Cd and Hg are not regarded as typical transition elements.

    They are d¹⁰ in the ground state and in their common ions.

  • Mercury is a liquid at room temperature; Zn and Cd melt unusually low.

    No unpaired d electrons for metallic bonding (plus relativistic effects for Hg).

  • Mn has an unexpectedly low melting point within the 3d series.

    The stable half filled d⁵ set makes its d electrons less available for metallic bonding.

  • Cu has a positive E∘(CuX2+/Cu)E^\circ(\ce{Cu^2+}/\ce{Cu}) and does not liberate HX2\ce{H2} from dilute acids.

    High atomisation plus ionisation enthalpy is not compensated by hydration enthalpy.

  • CuX+\ce{Cu+} disproportionates in water though d10d^{10} is stable.

    Much larger hydration enthalpy of Cu²⁺.

  • E∘(MX2+/M)E^\circ(\ce{M^2+}/\ce{M}) of Mn, Ni and Zn are more negative than expected.

    Stable d⁵ Mn²⁺ and d¹⁰ Zn²⁺; for Ni, the most negative hydration enthalpy of Ni²⁺.

  • The highest fluoride of Mn is MnFX4\ce{MnF4} though its highest oxide is MnX2OX7\ce{Mn2O7}.

    Oxygen forms multiple bonds to the metal.

  • MnOX4X−\ce{MnO4-} and CrX2OX7X2−\ce{Cr2O7^2-} are intensely coloured though the metal is d0d^0.

    Charge transfer from the oxygen ligands to the metal.

  • CoX3+\ce{Co^3+} is unstable in water but very stable in complexes like [Co(NHX3)X6]X3+\ce{[Co(NH3)6]^3+}.

    Strong field ligands give a large CFSE to low spin d⁶.

  • Zr and Hf have almost identical radii.

    Lanthanoid contraction.

  • CeX4+\ce{Ce^4+}, EuX2+\ce{Eu^2+} and YbX2+\ce{Yb^2+} exist although +3 is the normal lanthanoid state.

    They reach f⁰, f⁷ or f¹⁴.

  • The actinoid contraction is larger from element to element than the lanthanoid contraction.

    5f electrons shield even more poorly than 4f.

Coordination Compounds I: Werner, Nomenclature & Isomerism

Open chapter ›
  • Two different compounds (green and violet) share the formula CoClX3 ⋅ 4 NHX3\ce{CoCl3*4NH3} and both give 1 mol AgCl.

    They are trans and cis isomers, which is evidence for octahedral geometry.

  • Ethane-1,2-diamine (en) is bidentate but neutral.

    Two N lone pairs; no charge.

  • KX4[Fe(CN)X6]\ce{K4[Fe(CN)6]} gives no test for FeX2+\ce{Fe^2+}, while Mohr’s salt does.

    Complex ions do not dissociate into simple metal ions.

  • Tetrahedral complexes do not show geometrical isomerism.

    All four positions are adjacent to each other.

  • trans-[CoClX2(en)X2]X+\ce{[CoCl2(en)2]+} is optically inactive while the cis form is active.

    The trans form has a mirror plane.

  • Cisplatin is an anticancer drug but transplatin is inactive.

    Only the cis geometry can bind adjacent DNA bases.

  • Square planar [Pt(NHX3)X2ClX2]\ce{[Pt(NH3)2Cl2]} has two geometrical isomers but no optical isomers.

    The molecular plane is a mirror plane.

  • In [Fe(HX2O)X5(NO)]X2+\ce{[Fe(H2O)5(NO)]^2+} (brown ring) iron is +1.

    NO binds as NO⁺.

Coordination Compounds II: VBT, Crystal Field Theory & Carbonyls

Open chapter ›
  • [CoFX6]X3−\ce{[CoF6]^3-} is high spin and paramagnetic, unlike almost all Co(III) complexes.

    F⁻ is a weak field ligand.

  • Tetrahedral complexes are almost never low spin.

    Δt = 4/9 Δo is smaller than the pairing energy.

  • [Ni(CO)X4]\ce{[Ni(CO)4]} is tetrahedral and diamagnetic though Ni has 10 valence electrons as 3d84s23d^84s^2.

    CO pushes the 4s electrons into 3d (3d¹⁰), leaving sp³ orbitals for bonding.

  • PdX2+\ce{Pd^2+} and PtX2+\ce{Pt^2+} (d8d^8) complexes are square planar even with weak field ligands.

    Δ is much larger for 4d and 5d metals.

  • [Cu(NHX3)X4]X2+\ce{[Cu(NH3)4]^2+} is square planar though CuX2+\ce{Cu^2+} is d9d^9.

    Strong Jahn Teller distortion of d⁹.

  • [Fe(CN)X6]X4−\ce{[Fe(CN)6]^4-} is diamagnetic, though free FeX2+\ce{Fe^2+} has 4 unpaired electrons.

    Strong field CN⁻ gives low spin t₂g⁶.

  • [Ni(CN)X4]X2−\ce{[Ni(CN)4]^2-} is diamagnetic while [NiClX4]X2−\ce{[NiCl4]^2-} is paramagnetic.

    CN⁻ is strong field (dsp², square planar); Cl⁻ is weak field (sp³, tetrahedral).

  • CO is the strongest field ligand although it is a weak σ donor.

    It is an excellent π acceptor (back bonding).

  • Anhydrous CuSOX4\ce{CuSO4} is white; CuSOX4 ⋅ 5 HX2O\ce{CuSO4*5H2O} is blue.

    Without water ligands there is no crystal field splitting, so no d to d absorption.

  • ZnX2+\ce{Zn^2+} complexes are colourless.

    d¹⁰, so no d to d transitions are possible.

Organometallic Chemistry

Open chapter ›
  • V(CO)X6\ce{V(CO)6} is a stable 17 electron, paramagnetic monomer.

    Steric crowding prevents dimerisation; it is easily reduced to the 18 electron [V(CO)₆]⁻.

  • Mn(CO)X5\ce{Mn(CO)5} does not exist as a monomer; it dimerises to MnX2(CO)X10\ce{Mn2(CO)10}.

    A Mn–Mn bond brings each Mn to 18 electrons.

  • Wilkinson’s catalyst and Zeise’s salt are stable with only 16 electrons.

    Square planar d⁸ complexes leave the high energy pzp_z orbital empty.

  • Ethene binds side on (η²) in Zeise’s salt.

    Bonding uses the C=C π electrons, with back donation into π*.

  • Ferrocene undergoes Friedel Crafts acylation like an aromatic compound.

    The Cp rings are 6π aromatic systems.

  • Sodium ethoxide is not an organometallic compound although it contains a metal and carbon.

    There is no direct bond between the metal and carbon.

  • Vitamin B₁₂ coenzymes are naturally occurring organometallic compounds.

    Methylcobalamin and adenosylcobalamin have a Co–C bond.

Bioinorganic Chemistry

Open chapter ›
  • Haemocyanin carries oxygen with copper, not iron, and turns blue when oxygenated.

    Two Cu⁺ ions bind O₂ as peroxide, becoming Cu²⁺.

  • The central metal of chlorophyll is magnesium, not iron.

    Mg²⁺ suits the light harvesting chlorin ring.

  • Vitamin B₁₂ coenzymes contain a direct Co–C bond.

    They are natural organometallic compounds.

  • Haemoglobin binds O₂ cooperatively (sigmoidal curve); myoglobin does not.

    Communication between four subunits.

  • Nitrogenase always produces H₂ along with NH₃.

    Obligatory reduction of protons in the mechanism.

  • Iron(III) haemoglobin (methaemoglobin) cannot transport oxygen.

    O₂ binds only Fe(II) haem.

  • Fluoride protects teeth at about 1 ppm but damages them above about 2 ppm.

    Fluorapatite formation versus fluorosis.

  • Cd²⁺ is toxic although it is in the same group as essential Zn²⁺.

    It displaces Zn from enzymes and binds thiol groups strongly.

Metallurgy: Isolation of Metals

Open chapter ›
  • Iron pyrites (FeSX2\ce{FeS2}) is not used as an ore of iron.

    NCERT: the abundant oxide ores are preferred because they do not produce polluting gases such as the SO₂ released from pyrites.

  • The 2 C+OX2→2 CO\ce{2C + O2 -> 2CO} line has a negative slope in the Ellingham diagram.

    Gas moles increase, so ΔS is positive.

  • Below about 983 K CO is a better reductant than C; above it carbon is better.

    Crossing point of the CO→CO₂ and C→CO lines.

  • Aluminium is not extracted by carbon reduction.

    Al₂O₃ is extremely stable and carbon would form Al₄C₃ at the required temperature.

  • Copper needs no separate reducing agent in the converter.

    Self reduction: Cu₂S reduces Cu₂O.

  • Silver and gold are extracted by first oxidising them (with OX2\ce{O2}/CN⁻) and then reducing with Zn.

    Hydrometallurgy: soluble cyano complexes form only after oxidation.

  • In zone refining the impurities travel with the molten zone.

    They are more soluble in the melt than in the solid.

  • The graphite anodes are consumed in the Hall Héroult cell.

    Oxide ions discharge as O₂, which burns the carbon to CO and CO₂.

Qualitative Salt Analysis

Open chapter ›
  • PbX2+\ce{Pb^2+} appears in both group I and group II.

    PbCl₂ is partly soluble, so the remainder precipitates as PbS.

  • NH₄Cl must be added before NH₄OH in group III.

    The common ion effect keeps [OH⁻] low, so Mn and Mg hydroxides stay in solution (Zn²⁺ stays as an ammine complex).

  • FeX2+\ce{Fe^2+} is oxidised to FeX3+\ce{Fe^3+} before group III.

    Fe(OH)₂ is too soluble to precipitate completely.

  • Only chloride gives the chromyl chloride test; bromide and iodide do not, and covalent HgClX2\ce{HgCl2} does not respond.

    CrO₂Br₂ and CrO₂I₂ are not formed; HgCl₂ does not release Cl⁻ readily.

  • NHX4X+\ce{NH4+} is tested on the original salt, not during group analysis.

    Group reagents themselves contain NH₄⁺.

  • AgCl dissolves in NHX4OH\ce{NH4OH} but AgI does not.

    AgI has a far smaller Ksp than the stability of [Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺ can overcome.

  • PbIX2\ce{PbI2} dissolves in hot water and reappears as golden spangles on cooling.

    Its solubility rises sharply with temperature.

  • MgX2+\ce{Mg^2+} is in group VI, not group V.

    NH₄Cl keeps [CO₃²⁻] too low for MgCO₃ to precipitate.

  • ZnS is white while most other sulfides in groups II and IV are black.

    Zn²⁺ (d¹⁰) has no low energy charge transfer absorption in the visible region.

  • CdS (group II) is yellow, unlike the black CuS and PbS in the same group.

    Its band gap absorbs only blue light.